Filmmaking, Writing, Beer, Insularity, History, and Other Topics More-Or-Less Related to “Beer Wars,” Part 13

Part 1Part 2Part 3Part 4Part 5Part 6Part 7

Part 8Part 9Part 10Part 11Part 12Part 13

NOTE: When I moved to a new site, this “Beer Wars” series was mangled/destroyed during the move. I’ve reconstructed it by copying/pasting another copy of the original posts. I also lost the comments in their original form. I’ve copied/pasted the comments, but had to do so under my own name. So although it looks as though I’m the only commenter, I’m not. In each case, I’ve identified the original commenter.


Gloomy story, eh? Not entirely. American winemakers have shown that it’s possible to convey a different message.

Prior to the 1960s, the American wine industry was almost non-existent. Sure, a few families in California made a handful of wines, which was consumed by a tiny consumer audience. But the operative words are “few,” “handful,” and “tiny.” During the 1960s, however, a handful of wine enthusiasts began building an American wine industry. (*1) They built an audience for their product by promoting it specifically as a beverage for everyday use in the most common of all events: eating.

Unlike brewers, who marketed beer as the handmaiden of professional sports and young men, and unlike distillers, who didn’t do much marketing at all (in part for legal reasons that made it very difficult to advertise any kind of spirits), winemakers touted wine as a beverage to enjoy every day, especially with food.

The wine industry also lobbied for laws that legalized on-premise sales at their wineries, which enabled vineyards to become “tourist” destinations, and maintained a coherent message about wine’s role in daily life: It tastes good with food. Drink it with your meal instead of coffee, tea, or milk. (*2)

Put another way, they un-demonized wine. The winemakers also worked together as an industry to craft a single, coherent message. As a result, wine has become a staple ingredient in the American home. When I was growing up, I don’t remember anyone having wine in the house. By the time I was in my 20s (in the 1970s), wine had become common even in “low end” restaurants.” By the 1980s, wine had become a staple in grocery stores and in the American home.

But again, wine is the exception to the rule. And of the three categories of alcohol — wine, beer, and spirits — brewers have the longest road to travel to change beer’s image from drink-of-frat-boys to sophisticated beverage best enjoyed with food.

Yes, I know that craft brewers are working hard to create a new image. Craft brewers avoid advertisements designed around babes in bare skin, and promote beer/food pairings. But they’ve got a long way to go.

In my opinion, and as I’ve said here before, their best bet is to appeal to consumers’ ecological concerns.

A compelling discussion about how to do that is in Daniel Goleman’s new book Ecological Intelligence. For example, consumers will respond to a “drink local” message, but they need to see/hear that message at the point-of-sale rather than in nebulous advertisements that appeal to concerns about image or status.

In the meantime, brewers will, I hope, begin thinking about the 3-tier system less as some insitutional evil than as a symptom of a deeper problem.

And with that, dear (and patient!) readers, I bring this rambling discourse to an end.


*1: A truly good cultural history of the American wine industry is waiting to be written, but one place to start is Paul Lukacs, American Vintage: The Rise of American Wine.

*2: Winemakers lobbied for those laws in California in partnership with the half dozen or so craft beer makers, who wanted to sell beer at their “brewpubs.”

2 thoughts on “Filmmaking, Writing, Beer, Insularity, History, and Other Topics More-Or-Less Related to “Beer Wars,” Part 13

  1. This was originally posted by Brillo:I agree with your point about the drink local message. Craft brewers need to elicit from Americans some of the same feelings about their local beer as say, the Germans. While Germany does have its Becks and Loewenbraus, most of the drinking is still very regional. I remember growing up there, and when you were in ABCburg, you drank ABC Brau, and when you were in XYZstadt, you drank XYZ Brau. For much of the populace, craft beer still evokes feelings of elitism and pretentiousness. They say, “give me a good, honest American beer,” and order a Bud Light. Many still haven’t made the connection that there isn’t a more good, honest American beer than the one brewed 2 miles down the road, by their neighbor, whose kids go to school with theirs. Some places are starting to exhibit that normalization, like Fort Collins, or Portland, but they are the exception.As for your point about appealing to beer drinker’s ecological instincts, I think you have something there as well. New Belgium seems to really be capitalizing on this trend. It doesn’t take a genius to figure out that there is a strong correlation between those who would consider themselves ecologically conscious and those who drink craft beer. Unfortunately, environmentalism still has some of the same inroads to make as craft brewing. It carries with it some of those same elitist images as craft beer. Until the average American stops equating being green with a hairy-legged chick from San Francisco named Starbeam who wears hemp clothes and eats only kale, then the “green” market for craft brewers will remain limited.Luckily, the message that being environmentally conscious and energy efficient is actually one of the most American and patriotic things you can do is starting to sink in. I remember forward operating bases in Iraq trying to be as green as possible. We Marines realized that being efficient meant fewer gasoline convoys, which meant fewer IEDs, which meant fewer dead Marines. I know that is an extreme example, but hopefully that type of thinking will begin to affect all of us eventually. (Little bit of a tangent. Sorry).Ultimately, there is a budding desire in this country for slower, less processed, natural, local, and handmade; and I believe that the craft beer segment will benefit from this trend.

  2. Brillo, I think you’re probably right about why some people reject “craft” beer: they do equate it with being kind of snobby. It’s interesting that winemakers managed to overcome that. Sure, the world of wine is still rife with snobbery, but it’s amazing how many people do think of a good California table wine, for example, as being about on par with coffee or a cola.And I definitely think that the one way craft brewers will be able to make inroads is via the “ecological” angle. I already thought so, and have mentioned it many times here at the blog, but the point was really driven home this past week when I was reading Goleman’s new book “Ecological Intelligence.”


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s